|Written by||Michaela Muntean|
|Illustrator||Mary Grace Eubank|
|Series||Big Bird StoryMagic|
On a Spring day, the Birds-of-a-Feather Club are trying to earn their "Know-Your-Colors" badges and Little Bird asks Big Bird for help. First the birds paint yellow pictures in front of 123 Sesame Street, including pictures of Bees, Bananas and Prairie Dawn's hair. When they begin to paint blue pictures, including Grover on his bike, Cookie Monster comes by and crashes into Maxwell Bird, spilling his blue paint all over him.
The club moves to the park where Oscar the Grouch points out some green items for them to paint, including his friend Iggy the Inchworm, who falls into Buddy's paint, splashing green all over each of them. Becca Bird is knocked out of Frazzle's wagon, and falls into a patch of strawberries, turning red in the process.
Then the Orange family and the Purple family invite everyone over to their picnic lunch, but when everyone sat on the same side, it tips over, spilling grape jam over Billy Bird and orange juice over Holly Bird.
On their way home it begins to rain, and despite their hustle to get out of the rain, the birds are caught in the storm, only to discover that it has washed them clean, turning the birds yellow again. And when the short lasting storm passed, the group continued their pursuit of a badge by painting pictures of a rainbow.
Big Bird sings a song at the end of the tape, "Without Colors", and there is also a musical interlude listed on the tape as "Blue, Red, Green, Orange and Purple", which Big Bird sings after each color accident. Both are written by Dave Conner.