Muppet Wiki

Talk:2011

27,463pages on
this wiki

Back to page

Talk pages are no longer used.
Please use the Forum for discussing article changes.

What counts as an appearance?

With regards to the appearances section, what's fair game?

  • Do puppeteers talking about Muppet projects count? (Or documentaries about their work with the Muppets, as per Kevin Clash?
  • Do Jason Segel talk show appearances count? Unless Michael Caine did an appearance for Christmas Carol, this would be the first time a "human" has done solo appearances on in promotion of a Muppet movie, I'm guessing. (Or have Sesame cast done solo talk show appearances?)

Is there any policy established to either extent? -- Zanimum 00:11, October 26, 2011 (UTC)

I would be interested to know as well.--Gonzofan 03:27, October 26, 2011 (UTC)
Anyone? I feel that a legitimate question was posed here. Is there a policy on this? Ultimately, I think the question is, do "human" appearances by themselves count to be listed, or do we only document it if it involves a Muppet appearance? So in this case, do we bother to list an appearance by Kevin Clash, even though it was without Elmo?--Gonzofan 01:33, October 27, 2011 (UTC)
My feeling is that someone like Kevin Clash or Steve Whitmire doing an interview about a Muppet project should count, because they are major players. Frank Oz or Joey Mazzarino doing an interview about their latest stage show or movie would not. -- Nate (talk) 19:13, October 31, 2011 (UTC)
I think when a writer/director/producer/performer for a Muppet production makes an appearance to promote a Muppet project it should count as being relevant to the wiki - such as Jim Henson appearing on Good Morning America, Kevin Clash on The Daily Show, or Joey Mazzarino talking about Sesame Street on CNN. I wouldn't count appearances that aren't driven by their Muppet work (even if they happen to mention the Muppets) - such as Frank Oz promoting The Stepford Wives or something like that. I would count Segel's promotions for The Muppets (moreso then Cain in MCC or Curry in MTI, he's not just the top-billed human star; he's the co-writer and a produer too). I wouldn't count times he was out promoting How I Met Your Mother or some other film (even if he mentioned the Muppets); but if it is a Muppet-driven promotional appearance (even if the puppets aren't there) I would include it. -- Brad D. (talk) 16:12, November 2, 2011 (UTC)
Okay, so:
  • yes to actors appearing in Muppet-related projects, appearing to promote those projects,
  • yes to Muppeteers appearing to promote Muppet-related products,
  • no to Muppeteers promoting their own projects.
No one in disagreement to that? -- Zanimum 21:53, November 5, 2011 (UTC)
I agree. As long as it is a Muppet-based appearance, I think we should cover it on the Muppet-based wiki (even if the puppets themselves aren't on hand). -- Brad D. (talk) 23:57, November 5, 2011 (UTC)
Jeannette Betancourt
I agree to those three bullet points as well. —Scott (message me) 02:23, November 18, 2011 (UTC)
Okay, one more... SW staffer Jeannette Betancourt appeared on Tell Me More. Unlike most SW staffer appearances, she wasn't joined by a Muppet. I've mentioned it on the show page, but I presume I don't bother mention it in 2009? (She was talking about Talk, Listen, Connect: Changes, specifically.) -- Zanimum 18:33, November 28, 2011 (UTC)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki