This puppet later appeared in monster skits in Sesame Street's first season, with large pink eyelids added and his arms removed. He appears as Mrs. Trudy Monster in a game show sketch, "The Mr. and Mrs. Game", wearing a wig and necklace.
He also appeared in The Muppet Show: Sex and Violence in his Sesame Street get-up as part of the audience in the wrestling match.
Scudge has also had various performers in his appearances, including Jerry Juhl in the Christmas sketch, Jim Henson in the sketch where monsters look at "C", Frank Oz in "The Mr. and Mrs. Game" and the sketch where monsters look at "A", and Caroll Spinney in the "First and Last" sketch, among others.
Sesame Street sketches
|Picture||Theme / First Appearance||Description|
| "Some" and "All"|
|A group of Muppets, including Scudge, demonstrate "Some" and "All".|
| "The Mr. and Mrs. Game Show"|
|Scudge appears in "The Mr. and Mrs. Game" show as Beautiful Day Monster's wife.|
| Monsters look at "A"|
|Scudge is among the group of monsters who observe a giant letter "A".|
| Monsters and the letter "C"|
|A group of monsters, including Scudge, whisper the letter "C" to one another.|
| Professor Hastings' Feelings Lecture|
|Professor Hastings conducts a lecture about the ways people feel, but keeps drifting off. Meanwhile, two groups of Muppets behind him pass by; one cheering for their winning team, and the others crying for the losing team. Scudge is among those in the happy team.|
| "Here and There"|
|Scudge appears at the end of the original 1970 version of the "Here and There" sketch.|
| "First and Last"|
| A bearded hippie leads a group of monsters, among them are Scudge and the early Grover, in a game where they march in a line and then switch directions.