Sadie Schwartzbaum from Sausalito is a contestant on "Meal or No Meal." Guided by Howie Eatswell, Sadie must choose from five covered platters in search of a meal. Only one platter contains an actual full-balanced meal, while the others contain snacks and other goodies. As she plays, various offers of cookies are made to her by a mysterious silhouetted baker (later revealed to be Cookie Monster).

The puppet is made from a Large Light Pink Live Hand Anything Muppet, similar in design to its lavender counterpart.