Judy arrives on the street, needing a fairy godmother for her story and Abby Cadabby fits the bill. Judy is looking for a beast to be friends with. Abby conjures up a lobster and kangaroo for her, but they don't meet her needs. After browsing a book of animals, she finds herself entranced by the horse. Abby conjures one up, who becomes a quick friend to Judy. She rides her new friend off down the street, now having a happy ending.
Her character and story spoof that of Beauty and the Beast; Judy acknowledges this and claims "Beauty" is her cousin.