A different version of Herry's dad appears in "We All Sing Together".
- I am a Monster (1976) Here, Herry's Father looks much like the purple-nosed variant of Herry, except with a black handlebar mustache.
- Herry's dad appears in the 1983 book The Songs of Sesame Street in Poems and Pictures, illustrating the song "That Furry Blue Mommy of Mine". In that book, he looks like an older version of Herry, with a bushy black moustache and a pipe. He has a similar appearance in A Baby Sister for Herry.
- In the 1989 book It's No Fun to Be Sick!, Herry's Dad looks like Herry, with a blue moustache and suspenders.