Tiffy wants to cook her famous imagination salad, and is waiting for Finchen (who is bringing the special ingredient). Tiffy becomes frustrated, and Samson can't cheer her up. Rumpel suggests punishing Finchen for being unpunctual.
Grover is going to teach the audience about "surprise" by sneaking up on Ernie. He sees Ernie sitting in his chair. He knows that it's Ernie, because he can see Ernie's shirt and Ernie's hair. Grover sneaks up to surprise Ernie -- but then it turns out to be Herry Monster.
Ernie talks about what happens next when he throws a rubber ball, a glass and a watermelon over the wall.