Mando welcomes the viewer as he draws a portrait of himself. He finds himself joined by Elmo, Abby and Big Bird, all dressed in snazzy outfits for today's meeting of the Sesame Street Snazzy Society. They point out how snazzy the viewer looks too. They can't start without their president - Segi, when a snazzy chicken and penguin chorus introduce her ("Make Way for Her Snazziness"). As Mando heads off, Segi begins the meeting with the club dance - the "Snazzy Shuffle."
Next, Segi is going to read the latest addition to the Snazzy Jazzy book series - Snazzy Jazzy and the Snazziest Toy. In the book, Snazzy Jazzy tries to find the snazziest toy in the toy store. She happens upon a teddy bear, but finds it's too brown to be snazzy. Segi suddenly stops reading and runs off with the book.
Mando finds Segi just as she tosses her tiara into the trash. She explains that if Snazzy Jazzy doesn't think brown is snazzy, she can't be snazzy either because of her brown skin. She adds it's in a book, so it must be true. Mando calls out Leela and Chris and asks Segi if she finds them snazzy. They then sing "The Color of Me" to show her the different shades of brown and how great they can be. Elmo, Abby and Big Bird join the group to continue the meeting and Segi sees how snazzy she can be. They all dance to the "Snazzy Shuffle" once more.
This episode was originally scheduled to be Episode 4635 in the previous season and had aired internationally as such. When the episode was instead replaced with a Halloween-themed show, the episode was held over for this season.