Telly and Big Bird spend the morning in the garden, and decide to have lunch at Hooper's Store. The Amazing Mumford offers to take them there instantly, by magic. Telly wants to give it a try, but Big Bird would rather walk.

Unfortunately, Mumford can't quite remember the magic words, and he and Telly are magically transported to Big Bird's nest, and then to Oscar's trash can. In Mumford's next attempt, he lands them in the bathroom in Maria and Luis's apartment, where Maria is taking a shower. Mumford quickly casts the spell again, and they end up in Arizona, then at the North Pole. Meanwhile, Big Bird and Alan wait impatiently at Hooper's for Telly to arrive.

Finally, Telly finds a pay phone, and calls Big Bird to explain why they're late. Big Bird tells them that their sandwiches are ready -- and when Mumford hears the name of the sandwich that Big Bird is going to have, he remembers the magic words: "A la peanut butter and jelly sandwiches!" The pair is magically transported to Hooper's Store, where they can enjoy a well-deserved lunch.

Segments

• Nathan Lane performs "Sing" with the Oinker Sisters. (EKA: Episode 3856)
• Cookie Monster demonstrates "between" with a cookie sandwich. (EKA: Episode 3723)
• Elmo sings "In Your Imagination". (EKA: Episode 3119)
• Song: Joe Raposo sings "Everybody Eats" (re-filmed version) (EKA: Episode 2885)
• Cartoon: Suzie Kabloozie and Feff appear to float around in outer space, but at the end of the sketch, it is revealed that they are just pretending to be astronauts. (EKA: Episode 3701)
• Song: "Walk!" (EKA: Episode 3851)
• Film: Wegman dogs form a W.
• Cartoon: W for Witch (EKA: Episode 2407)
• Elmo's World: Transportation (EKA: Episode 3817)