Wembley changes places with his lookalike, the traveling Wizard of Fraggle Rock, who says he wants peace and quiet. Wembley thinks his new disguise will be an easy way to get attention, but the Wizard has a sinister motive for wanting to swap identities. Wizard helps Wembley with his beard by using an experiment glue made by the Doozers. Things get worse when a Poison Cackler that had been chasing the Wizard shows up.
Meanwhile, Doc and Sprocket try a rope trick to start a magic act which goes horribly awry.
On Trophy Day, every Fraggle gets to pick his own trophy, for whatever he feels proud of. In this episode, Gobo gets a trophy for seeing a poison cackler without it seeing him. Wembley chooses the same trophy he always chooses -- Best Shirt with Banana Trees on It.
This episode was co-written by John Pattison, a Fraggle Rock puppeteer who plays Henchy Fraggle and Begoony.