|Picture||Summary / First Appearance||Description|
| Abby's Wand|
| Abby Cadabby surprises Elmo, and demonstrates her feats of magic, such as disappearing and turning a mailbox into a pumpkin. Her wand can also be used as a back scratcher.
| Same and Different|
| Elmo and Abby Cadabby point out the ways that they're the same and different, and Elmo imagines himself as a pink fairy monster.
| Making a Doll|
| Abby Cadabby plays with her doll, Prince, when Elmo meets up with her and wishes he had a doll with him. Abby plans to conjure up him one, but makes a pumpkin, then a hat and finally a marker. Elmo puts all those things to make a doll of his own.
| Making a Friend|
| Elmo looks for a friend to play with when Abby Cadabby shows up, who thinks she can make a friend for him appear. First, she tries making Dorothy appear, but makes a pumpkin in a fish bowl. Then, she tries making Bert appear, but conjures a pumpkin with Bert’s hair style. Abby thinks she’s a failure, until Elmo points out she did bring a friend to play with – her!
| Two is You and Me|
| Elmo and Abby count to two, counting Abby's pairs of pigtails and hands, as well as Elmo's eyes and feet. When Abby thinks there's nothing left to count, she realizes that they themselves are "one, two friends," which leads to a new rendition of "Two is You and Me."
| I Can Sing|
| Elmo and Abby Cadabby perform a new version of "I Can Sing."
|Drum Exercise|| Abby performs her wing exercises, but is disrupted by Elmo, who's doing his drum practice. They cooperate by having Abby exercise to Elmo's drumming.
|Paper|| After Abby finishes coloring her paper, she plans on throwing it out. Elmo has different plans for it - he recycles it into a paper airplane for them to play with.
|Pretend Teeth|| Elmo and Abby plan on showing the viewer how to brush their teeth, but since they don't have any, they pretend they have teeth.
|Jump Rope Frustration|| Abby becomes frustrated when she's unable to use her jump rope. Elmo explains that everyone gets that way when they can't do something. He offers his help, but then he is unable to use it. They decide to just jump without the rope instead.
|Pretending|| Abby and Elmo use their imaginations to play "Monkeys in Space".
|Bike Safety|| Elmo wishes he could ride a big bike, but feels he's not ready yet. Abby takes this as a lack of safety gear and magically gives Elmo a helmet, pads, and a pillow to protect him. Elmo clarifies to Abby that he doesn't know how to ride a two-wheeler, but wants to learn someday. He settles with riding his tricycle instead, until he realizes that he's too protected.