Chauncey the Turtle is a sea turtle on The Animal Show who appears in Episode 109: Wildebeest & Turtle. He tells Stinky the Skunk and Jake the Polar Bear about turtles and how sea turtles migrate. He also sings "My Shell is a Part of Me (If the Shell Fits, Wear It)."

The puppet later appeared alongside Jeremiah Tortoise at Wilson's Pet Store for Kermit's Swamp Years.