"A Nice Boy Like Me," originally co-written and performed by Barry Manilow, is performed by Sandy Duncan as "A Nice Girl Like Me" on episode 114 of The Muppet Show.

In the opening number, Sandy sings, dances, and downs shot after shot in a bar with Sweetums, all three Mutations, and the black-haired, male Full-Bodied Humanoid. Dr. Teeth, Zoot, and Animal provide the music; Beautiful Day Monster is the bartender; and Scoff and its green counterpart look on from above.